Why the Court of Appeal’s decision signals a turning point for Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) refund claims
A recent ruling by the Court of Appeal in Mudan & Anor v HMRC has confirmed that properties in need of repair are still subject to residential rates of Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT). The decision reinforces HM Revenue & Customs’s long-standing position that if a property retains the fundamental characteristics of a dwelling, particularly, where it has previously been used as one, it remains chargeable at residential rates, even if significant works are required.
This has important implications for homeowners who were encouraged to submit SDLT repayment claims on the basis that their property was “uninhabitable” at the time of purchase. In recent years, a number of unregulated firms have promoted such claims, often charging substantial contingent fees. While refunds were sometimes issued initially, HMRC is now actively reviewing and challenging many of them.
For some homeowners, this has resulted in unexpected demands to repay tax, together with interest and potential penalties.
If a HMRC enquiry or repayment demand is received, the key thing is not to ignore it but seek independent advice from a qualified tax adviser or solicitor experienced in SDLT and HMRC enquiries, not the firm that made the original claim.
Gather your documentation, including the SDLT return, HMRC refund confirmation, purchase documents, surveys, and all correspondence with the claims company. Assess your position realistically. If the claim is unlikely to succeed in light of recent case law, resolving the issue promptly may reduce further interest and penalties. Instead it is better to consider recourse against the claims company if you believe the claim was negligently prepared or misrepresented.
Taking early, professional advice can significantly reduce both financial exposure and stress. For those concerned about a previous SDLT refund or have received correspondence from HMRC, now is the time to act. A proactive and informed approach will always place you in a stronger position than waiting for matters to escalate.