European real estate association partners announce winner of prestigious 2021 research prize

white and blue concrete building

The European Association for Investors in Non-listed Real Estate Vehicles (INREV), the Investment Property Forum (IPF) and the Society of Property Researchers (SPR) – co-sponsors of the Nick Tyrell Research Prize – have announced the 2021 winning research paper, awarding the prize to joint authors Franz Fuerst, Nick Mansley and Zilong Wang of the Department of Land Economy, University of Cambridge.

Entitled ‘Do Specialist Funds Outperform? Evidence from European Non-listed Funds’, the paper explores the extent to which specialisation can lead to outperformance for European non-listed real estate funds. Based on an analysis of the performance of 592 funds over nearly two decades between 2001 and 2019, the research concludes that both country specialisation and a combination of a country and sector specialisation are indeed associated with superior performance, but that sector specialisation alone is not. The empirical evidence points to the fact that specialists exhibit higher total returns both on a raw unadjusted basis and also when accounting for differences in fund and market characteristics. The results indicate the importance of being able to access local knowledge and expertise and that implied information advantages and local investment managers’ market knowledge and networks may be difficult to replicate.

Andrew Smith, Chair of the Judging Panel commented: “This year’s prize attracted some strong submissions on a very diverse range of topics. The winning paper was selected on the basis of both its practical relevance to the industry and the quality of the underlying research, in the best traditions of the Nick Tyrrell Research
Prize. Although there is extensive research in the area of fund selection, the authors break new ground by taking account of leverage and other important structural differences between funds that have not necessarily been captured by previous studies. The judges were impressed by a well-written and robustly supported paper, with clear, straightforward and actionable conclusions.”

Speaking on behalf of all three authors of the prize-winning paper, Nick Mansley said: “We are absolutely delighted to receive the prestigious Nick Tyrrell Research Prize. We love doing research which is of interest to both practitioners and academics and really enjoyed examining this challenging issue in a rigorous way. We hope it sparks interesting discussions across the industry about what managers are really good at.”

The winning paper was selected from strong submissions from across the globe. The authors will present their paper at a special industry seminar/webinar on 9 December 2021 and the paper has been published on Science Direct. An abstract is also available on each of the sponsoring organisations’ websites: INREV, IPF, SPR.

The 2021 Judging Panel comprised Andrew Smith (Hearthstone Investments Ltd.) (Chair), Dr Alexandra Krystalogianni, Dr Russell Chaplin (Intrinsic Value Real Estate Advisers) Mahdi Mokrane (PATRIZIA AG) and Prof. Simon Stevenson (Strome College of Business, Old Dominion University). The deadline for the 2022 Prize will be 31 May 2022. All submissions should be made through the secretariat for the prize, which is managed by Dr Paul Kennedy and Iryna Pylypchuk at nicktyrrellprize@inrev.org.

What do you feel about this?