The truth of the Housing Market: Media Spin vs Reality
With all of the uncertainty and headlines surrounding the housing market at the moment, it’s easy to understand the level of panic and unease, with many people suggesting we’re headed for a significant downturn in the market.
The media certainly doesn’t help in this regard, with the dramatic and sensationalist headlines. There is always more to consider when it comes to the actual ‘real data’ surrounding the property market. In our role, advising our clients, who place a great deal of trust in our advice, it’s no surprise the most common question we are asked at the moment is what we predict for the housing market.
In this regard, one of the best sources of factual and reliable data, we can actually rely upon, is the RightMove index. This, in my view, is based on genuine ‘real-time live data’ that identifies actual real trends in buyer and seller activity, not just media hype and ‘fake news’.
According to RightMove in their latest House Price Index, posted just this week, it suggests that in the past month, buyer demand has risen by +20% on the pre-COVID-19 five-year average. This recent rise in seller asking prices is also in line with the ten-year September average increase of 0.6%. Paints a positive confident picture of the market doesn’t it?
It sure does, the headlines from this index are interestingly positive for the housing market suggesting that there is a “resilience to the market despite economic pressures”.
Well why is it then, that many (well most) mainstream media outlets seem to choose to ignore the ‘real’ data, in a bid to sensationalise, suggesting “an impending market crash” with some outlets quoting potential price falls of “as much as 15-20%”.
I suppose sensationalism sells? Maybe once upon a time it did at least. Nowadays we live in a world of real time social media, global data analytics at the touch of a button, 24/7. Also, let’s be honest, these days, every time we switch on our devices or turn on the TV/radio, we see scary reports about the latest crisis.
It’s no surprise then, if many people have become immune to the media headlines and opt to make their own decisions that work best for them and their families.
From a small business perspective, one interesting fact to note is that the total number of survey & valuation instructions was largely the same for September 2022 when compared year on year. Not only this, levels of instruction are also up on previous years of 2019 & 2020. This, despite all of the headlines of global and national uncertainty shows consistency in our local markets. Whilst I accept this can be down to regional variances, it paints a different story.
We only need to look back over the past 5 years to see difficult events such as Brexit, Covid-19, Lockdowns, Political Dramas, War in Europe, Cost of living crisis, Interest Rate rises, Pounds value against the Dollar. It’s not surprising then, that these days, many people often wake up thinking what new crisis are we faced with today?
Maybe as a result of the very many global and national events, people have somehow developed a tolerance to these major headlines and events, that they simply ‘can’t control’ or simply feel like looking to make decisions that have their own interests at heart, and in doing so, worry about the things that they can control or that suit their personal situation.
Covid for instance, has certainly shaped the way many of our clients look at property in terms of their needs and wants, whether that be downsizing to be closer to their families, or relocating to the seaside or countryside as they can remote work in a cloud based economy, bigger gardens or simply a garden at all.
You get the gist! My point is, many people have learnt to deal with crisis moments and the recent challenges on many levels, and whilst, of course, there are still more challenges ahead, people will still always want to buy their first home or aspire to something bigger, smaller, greener or now more than ever, perhaps cheaper to run etc.
In terms of marketed properties, buyer demand and transaction levels, here in the Midlands region, our surveyors and agency contacts are all still reporting that demand for property continues to outstrip supply. There does not seem to be, at least from the feedback and the activity levels seen locally at least. Also, we need to look at RightMove index data to determine if anything is changing anytime soon.
In terms of feedback from our financial contacts, the lending industry remains robust and well positioned to continue to lend money. Whilst media headlines suggest lenders are pulling mortgage products off the shelves, this is simply not true from what we’ve seen or heard of.
Yes they have refreshed their product offerings, and yes it has certainly become more expensive to borrow money. Of that we can be sure. However, lenders are not panicking. In fact they remain well positioned and responsible lending and affordability checks will ensure stability continues in this market.
In terms of the shorter term outlook, both the average asking price on a national level and by market sector, YOY, remains positive. This is despite FTB asking prices in particular seeing the slowest gains. However, with the SDLT changes, maybe this will provide continued growth and demand in this part of the market. This will likely result in pressure on the upper tiers.
It’s also interesting to note that the number of homes coming to market has risen back to 2019 levels, giving buyers more choice.
Buyer demand in the 3 and 4 bedroom sectors of the market is up by 2% even compared to the frenetic market of last year. In addition, more choices are also available this year compared with 2021. On a local regional level within the West Midlands, whilst in September asking prices were down -0.4% pricing has grown by 10.4% year on year. These stats suggest that despite all the events, and at a time when personal finances are stretched, there is still a strong demand to move home.
Maybe, what we are currently seeing with rising interest rates, stronger affordability checks, re-organised mortgage products, are simply the powers that be applying the brakes in an orderly fashion to slow the market to its new normal, whatever that looks like?
From the data coming out of RightMove and their index and from those working at the coal face, it feels like the housing market genuinely does feel well placed to continue to remain robust despite media spin and sensationalism.
One of the biggest challenges ahead remains interest rates, mortgage products and of course affordability. By having raised interest rates sharply, without much warnings, and with mini budget statements not having been well thought out, this quite rightly has caused a significant short term reaction in the markets and confidence levels.
But this will hopefully settle down, and as I’m writing this, the pound has already bounced back against the dollar and lenders have already replaced various mortgage products on the market, which, granted, are now more expensive with more stringent stress tests on applications.
The fact is, that the banks will need to ‘lend to make money’ and they will need to support families now more than ever as it is in no one’s interest to just leave people to struggle by or fail on their mortgage. This has been demonstrated during covid, and they will need to step up their game in the times ahead to ensure they provide stability and confidence to the market.
Whilst of course, we have no crystal ball (wish we did!!) and I am not naive to the challenges ahead, it is perhaps not all the doom and gloom as the media will have you believe?