Tenant choice and strong standards must sit at the heart of deposit alternatives, says flatfair CEO

Gary-Wright-,-CEO,-flatfair

Gary Wright, CEO of flatfair

flatfair has responded to recent Citizens Advice findings on renters’ experiences with deposits and deposit alternatives, saying the priority for the sector should be ensuring tenants are given genuine choice, clear information and strong protections throughout the rental journey.

Citizens Advice has raised concerns that some renters using deposit alternative products may not always feel they have been given a clear choice, with some tenants reportedly feeling pressured or misled when arranging a tenancy.

 

Gary Wright, CEO of deposit alternative specialists, flatfair, said the findings should be taken seriously by the wider lettings industry.

“The findings from Citizens Advice are concerning and should not be dismissed,” said Wright.

“Any situation where a tenant feels pressured, misled or unclear on their options is bad for renters, bad for landlords and bad for trust in the lettings sector.”

 

Wright said that addressing these concerns requires more than regulatory oversight and depends on how products are introduced and managed in practice.

“Tenants should always be able to make a clear and informed decision about how they meet their deposit obligations,” he said.

“That means clear information, transparent pricing, straightforward documentation and processes that ensure a deposit alternative is presented as a genuine option rather than a default requirement.”

 

flatfair supports this through structured partner onboarding, clear guidance for agents on how its products should be presented and a customer journey designed to ensure tenants understand the choices available to them before proceeding.

“Regulation has an important role to play, but it is not the be all and end all,” Wright said.

“Good controls are good controls, whether they are written into regulation or built into the way a responsible provider chooses to operate.”

 

According to flatfair, the most important issue is whether tenants are given genuine choice and clear information before deciding how to manage their deposit obligations.

“A deposit alternative should never feel mandatory, confusing or like a way around consumer protection,” said Wright.

“It should be a genuine choice for the tenant, clearly explained, properly controlled and supported throughout the tenancy.”

 

flatfair says its model is designed to provide tenants with clear information, access to support and an alternative to tying up a traditional cash deposit, while still giving landlords strong protection against loss or damage.

“Where agents offer both traditional deposits and deposit alternatives, tenants are able to choose the option that works best for their circumstances,” Wright said.

“Preserving that choice is essential if the sector wants to improve affordability and flexibility while maintaining trust.”

 

He added: “At flatfair, we have built our approach around transparency, tenant support and robust controls. Tenants need to understand what they are choosing, agents need clear guidance on how products should be introduced, and landlords need confidence that they are still properly protected.”

 

flatfair also noted that the Citizens Advice report highlights wider concerns across the rental sector, including issues relating to traditional cash deposits and tenancy processes more generally.

Wright said this demonstrates the importance of maintaining high standards and clear communication across all tenancy products, regardless of how a deposit is structured.

“The sector should be aiming higher than minimum compliance,” Wright said. “Regulation can set the floor, but responsible product design, clear tenant choice, strong oversight and good day-to-day controls are what raise standards in the real world.”

 

flatfair says it remains committed to working with agents, landlords, tenants and policymakers to support better outcomes across the rental market.

“The lesson from this report is not that innovation should be discouraged,” Wright concluded.

“It is that innovation must be accompanied by transparency, genuine tenant choice and strong operational standards. When those foundations are in place, tenants benefit from greater flexibility, landlords remain protected and agents can offer solutions with confidence.”

“The rental market works best when tenants and landlords both have confidence in the process. That means clear choices for renters, practical support when they need it, and market-leading protection for landlords. That is where the industry needs to focus.”

 

What do you feel about this?